Exploring the role of AI, human intelligence, and what it all means for small businesses.
I started researching artificial intelligence for a fairly straightforward reason: I wanted to understand what it might mean for my profession.
As a Virtual Assistant, it’s difficult to ignore the headlines. AI can write emails, manage schedules, summarise meetings, research information, create content, and automate administrative tasks.
Hang on a minute. Isn’t that rather a lot of what I do?
So I started investigating. Was AI about to make Virtual Assistants redundant? Would small business owners soon be able to manage everything themselves with a few clever prompts?
But the more I researched, the more I realised this was about something much bigger than the future of my own industry. It raised questions about how we work, how we think, how we make decisions and, ultimately, how much control we’re prepared to hand over to technology.
And I’m not entirely sure we’ve worked out the answers yet.
There’s no denying that AI is an extraordinary tool. It can help draft content, organise information, generate ideas, summarise documents and tackle repetitive tasks in a fraction of the time they might otherwise take.
I use it myself. For a range of things, from summarising information or finding information in a 100+ page document, or to adding a different perspective, but nothing goes out to a client without me reading it first.
For a small business owner juggling clients, finances, marketing and administration, that could be transformative. But does that mean you no longer need human assistance?
I don’t think it’s quite that simple.
Imagine you’re a business owner returning from an overnight flight. You’re exhausted, you haven’t slept properly, and you have a busy week ahead.
An AI scheduling tool might spot three available spaces in your diary and happily book three important pitch meetings for the morning after you land. Technically, it’s done its job.
But someone who knows you, understands your business and remembers that you’re practically useless after a red-eye flight might make a very different decision. They might protect that morning, rearrange your meetings and give you the breathing space to turn up at your best.
That’s the difference between completing a task and understanding the person behind it.
A good Virtual Assistant brings judgement, initiative, emotional intelligence, relationships and accountability. They notice when something doesn’t feel right. They anticipate problems. They understand priorities that don’t always appear in a written instruction. And sometimes, they know when to challenge a decision rather than simply carry it out.
AI can certainly support many of these activities. But knowing a business isn’t just about having access to information. It’s about understanding its people, relationships and unwritten rules.
I started watching talks and reading research into the wider implications of AI, a TED Talk from Yoshua Benjamin to name just one, and one question particularly caught my attention:
If AI makes thinking easier, could we gradually become less inclined to think for ourselves?
It turns out researchers are asking the same thing. In 2025, Microsoft and Carnegie Mellon University surveyed 319 knowledge workers who use AI tools every week. They found that the more people trusted AI to handle a task, the less critical thinking they tended to put into checking what it produced. People who were confident in their own abilities, on the other hand, did more.
Another study, from MIT’s Media Lab, monitored people’s brain activity while they wrote essays using ChatGPT, a search engine, or nothing at all. The ChatGPT group showed the lowest brain engagement. It was a small, early study that hadn’t been peer-reviewed, so I wouldn’t draw sweeping conclusions from it, but it’s certainly food for thought.
It’s tempting to accept a well-written AI response because it sounds convincing. We’ve probably all done it. But sounding convincing and being correct are two very different things.
And there’s another question worth asking: if AI gives us an answer immediately, do we miss out on the creative process of getting there ourselves?
Think about brainstorming. Sometimes the best ideas come from a slightly ridiculous suggestion, a conversation that goes off on a tangent, or someone challenging the obvious solution. If we jump straight to an AI-generated list of polished ideas, are we gaining efficiency but potentially losing something valuable along the way?
I’m not suggesting we abandon AI and return to doing everything manually. Far from it. But perhaps we need to distinguish between using AI to support our thinking and using AI instead of thinking.
For small business owners, that distinction matters. Your creativity, experience and ability to make good decisions are often what make your business different from everyone else’s. They’re worth protecting.
The more capable AI becomes, the more tempting it is to give it access to our systems and let it get on with things. And increasingly, AI tools are moving beyond simply generating information towards taking actions on our behalf.
That could be incredibly useful. Imagine an assistant that can manage routine enquiries, update systems, organise appointments and coordinate administrative processes.
But what happens when it gets something wrong? Who checks the information before it goes to a client? Who decides what confidential data it should be allowed to access? Who takes responsibility for the outcome?
For small businesses, these aren’t abstract questions. They’re practical concerns involving customer relationships, commercially sensitive information, finances and reputation.
An incorrect social media caption is one thing. An incorrect payment instruction or a confidential document sent to the wrong person is quite another.
It’s also worth thinking about what we share with these tools in the first place. It’s easy to paste a client’s email, contract or personal details into an AI tool without a second thought, but under UK GDPR you’re still responsible for how that information is handled. Before using any tool with client data, it’s worth checking where that data goes and how it’s stored.
We need to think carefully about the boundaries and safeguards we put around these tools. Just because AI can do something doesn’t automatically mean we should let it.
Despite everything I’ve read, I’m not anti-AI. Quite the opposite. I think it offers enormous opportunities, particularly for smaller businesses that don’t have the resources of large organisations.
But I increasingly believe the best approach comes down to three things.
AI is most useful when we give it a clear purpose. What problem are we trying to solve? Which tasks genuinely benefit from automation? Where could it free up time for more valuable work?
Rather than adopting every new tool because everyone else seems to be using it, we should think about how it fits into the way our business actually operates.
It’s about choosing the right tools, giving them the right instructions, and knowing when human involvement is needed. Even that scheduling tool might have got it right if someone had told it to keep mornings free after long-haul flights. But someone has to know that’s needed in the first place.
We need sensible boundaries. That means protecting confidential information, checking important outputs, understanding what systems AI can access, and making sure someone remains accountable.
For me, the aim shouldn’t be to remove humans from every process. It should be to use technology intelligently while retaining the judgement and oversight that good businesses depend on.
This is perhaps the most exciting part. If AI helps us complete routine work more efficiently, what do we do with the time we’ve gained?
For a Virtual Assistant, it might mean being able to support more clients or spend more time on the work that requires judgement and personal attention.
For a small business owner, it might mean developing new services, strengthening client relationships, pursuing opportunities, or simply getting some of their life back. After all, wasn’t that one of the reasons many of us started our own businesses in the first place?
The real opportunity isn’t necessarily to fill every hour with more work. It’s to make better use of the hours we have.
When I started this research, I thought I was investigating whether AI might replace my job. I’ve ended up asking a much broader question:
How do we embrace a technology that can do so much for us without losing the skills and human qualities that make us valuable?
I don’t have a definitive answer.
I do think the role of the Virtual Assistant will continue to evolve. Some tasks will become automated, new responsibilities will emerge, and the way we support businesses will change.
Increasingly, that’s how I see my own role: not competing with AI, but helping clients use it well. That means choosing the right tools, checking what they produce and making sure a real person is still keeping an eye on things.
Understanding people, building trust, exercising judgement, and taking responsibility will remain incredibly important. The same applies to small business owners. AI might help you run your business more efficiently, but it shouldn’t be the thing that decides what kind of business you want to run.
So, for now, my approach is to stay curious, keep learning, question what I’m being told, and embrace the tools that genuinely make a difference.
If you’d like a human keeping an eye on things — get in touch at plangenatalie@gmail.com. And I’d love to hear how you’re using AI in your own work.
07778 375777
